Eric foners new book, the second founding, argues that the failed. State rights meant the states wanted the more power than the government so they could do things the way they wanted them done. States rights definition of states rights by the free. According to this narrative, the civil war was not fought over slavery but rather. As a result, after the southern states seceded and the civil war broke out, granting states rights was the goal of both abraham lincoln, who desperately wanted to keep the united states united, and. Civil war definition, a war between political factions or regions within the same country. The enumerated powers that are listed in the constitution include exclusive federal powers, as well as concurrent powers that are shared with the states, and all of those powers are contrasted with the reserved powersalso called.
Six books on the civil war these six histories of the civil war that are mustreads if you want to better understand the conflict. What were the states rights and how did they cause the civil. At the start of the civil war, states rights was initially a unifying principle around which southerners rallied to the confederate cause, but the demands of war forced government and political officials to abandon their high ideals. Apr 08, 2015 for the last time, the american civil war was not about states rights.
States rights during civil war and reconstruction essay. A big issue right before the civil war was how much power the federal goverment really should have over its people. Exactly whichand whosestates rights were the casus belli in the civil war. Secession was based on the idea of state rights or states rights, a variant that came into use after the civil war. During the civil wars sesquicentennial, revisit a book.
In his book the american civil war, john keegan writes that the american civil war was to prove one of the most ferocious wars ever fought. Egalitarianism from french egal, meaning equal, or equalitarianism, is a school of thought within political philosophy that prioritizes equality for all people. The doctrine was most fully articulated in the writings of south carolina statesman and political theorist john c. The kidnapping of president lincoln and other war detective stories. Search the worlds most comprehensive index of fulltext books. Sep 22, 2017 among the most important, but commonly forgotten, advocates of states rights were the antislavery activists who launched the republican party in the 1850s. The postworld war ii era saw an increase in civil rights activities in the african american community, with a focus on ensuring that black citizens were able to vote. Meaning, pronunciation, translations and examples log in dictionary. Mar 05, 2017 all other factors noted, ultimately, the civil war was about slavery.
Texas students will soon learn slavery played a central. The southern states belived that each state government should have more power, and should be able to make important desions on its own. By the 1990s, publishers like pelican books of gretna, louisiana, offered. The lost cause of the confederacy, or simply the lost cause, is an american pseudohistorical, negationist ideology that holds that the cause of the confederacy during the american civil war was a just and heroic one. Board of education decision that outlawed legal segregation in the south and to the civil rights laws of the 1960s. Texas students will soon learn slavery played a central role in the civil war the states previous social studies standards listed three causes for the civil war. The civil war lasted for four years and left over 600,000 soldiers dead. Civil war causes states rights secession constitution powers. Dec 31, 2016 the civil war was not about states rights except for one particular right. Long after the civil war ended, one conflict raged on.
Egalitarian doctrines are generally characterized by the idea that all humans are equal in fundamental worth or moral status. A relative of several prominent south carolinians, gist rose to fame during the war but was killed at the battle of franklin on november 30. The people in the north belived in a strong federal government. In american political discourse, states rights are political powers held for the state governments rather than the federal government according to the united states constitution, reflecting especially the enumerated powers of congress and the tenth amendment. In american schools the civil war is a one trick pony. The states rights doctrine has no foundation in the era of abraham lincoln. How textbooks can teach different versions of history. Revisiting one of the most important and confounding books ever written about the civil war. That was the key piece of legislation that southern states demanded as a condition of calif. Five myths about why the south seceded washington post. From james mcphersons definitive history to tony horwitzs adventures among obsessives, here are the 11 best books on the civil war in time for the. The ideology endorses the supposed virtues of the antebellum south, viewing the war as a struggle primarily to save the southern way of life, or to defend states rights, in. Its all politics slavery was the civil war s cause despite revisionists saying otherwise. States rights during civil war and reconstruction during the mid1800s, states rights were a subject of much controversy and disagreement.
The original thirteen colonies in america in the 1700s, separated from the mother country in europe by a. After the american civil war the principle of states rights was invoked in an attempt to abolish civil rights for black citizens and to prevent the passage of child labor and antilynching laws. This is especially true of teaching the civil waran era in u. Npr ed about 5 million public school students in texas this year will get new and controversial textbooks. Some, however, believe that it was actually about states rights, or the rights of states to govern themselves. The killer angels by michael shaara, gone with the wind by margaret mitchell, cold mountain by charles frazier, gods. South carolina was further upset that new york no longer allowed slavery transit. The southern states viewed this as a violation of their constitutional rights, and. The civil war was about slavery, but it wasnt just about slavery.
From the early 1800s until the end of the civil war in 1865, states rights played a major role in the u. The states rights argument has lingered for decades, in part because many southerners. Texas will finally teach that slavery was main cause of. Most books and articles about the civil war cover the subject chronologically and examine the war as one continuous event, but civil war state by state looks at the war from the perspective of the fortyfive states and territories that existed during the period. States rights and historical malpractice teaching tolerance. The american civil war was about the attempted secession of certain states from the union. Even though the breaking point of the states rights argument was the issue of slavery, the states rights issue has been debated since the beginning of americas independence, as debated between hamilton and jefferson. Sectionalism, protectionism, and states rights were also major factors. A century and a half after the civil war ended, the struggle to define. Calhoun contended that if acts of the federal government ran contrary to state or local interests, then states had the right to nullify said acts. Apr 12, 2011 slavery, not states rights, caused civil war whose political effects linger.
Likewise, the us civil war was the result of a number of poorlyconceived compromises that kicked important issues like slavery and state s rights down the road for another generation to deal with. Reference books on the civil war national archives. Consider the fact that hamilton, jefferson, and washington were already arguing over the scope and ruling authority of the us government in the. According to the merriamwebster dictionary, the term. Federal rights meant the government wanted more power over the states so they could have certain rules everyone has to follow. Anybody who tells you otherwise is acting as an apologist and historical revisionist. Nov 01, 20 president lincoln did not see the civil war as a war to end slavery until that became necessary to stop european powers from recognizing the south lincoln said in his 1 st inaugural address, i have no purpose, directly or indirectly, to interfere with the institution of slavery in the states where it exists. Fox, a historian, were 360,222 from the north and 258,000 from the south. Bibliography of american civil war homefront wikipedia.
Civil rights are the rights that people have in a society to equal treatment and equal. Civil rights definition and meaning collins english. Facts, information and articles about states rights, one of the causes of the civil war states rights summary. Armies and soldiers genealogy general government documents guides to records in the national archives laws maps military operations personal papers and other archival collections the list below is highly selective. It was all about slavery and that is all it was about. States rights is seen as one of the major causes of the civil war. States rights is a term used to describe the ongoing struggle over political power in the united states between the federal government and individual states as broadly outlined in the tenth amendment and whether the usa is a single entity or an amalgamation of independent nations. Short stories, american, united states history civil war, 18611865 fiction. Another states rights dispute occurred over the war of 1812.
It is generally known in the south as the war between the states and is also called the war of the rebellion the official union designation, the war of secession, and the war for southern independence. Today, the states rights shorthand for the war is both a staple of u. As i explored more thoroughly in a recent journal of the civil war era article, early republicans used states rights to win voter support and to challenge proslavery federal policies. There are over 60,000 books on the war, with more appearing each month.
Was the united states civil war over states rights as it. This exalted the powers of the individual states as opposed to those of the federal government. I believe that the maintenance of the rights and authority reserved to the states and to the people are the safeguard to the continuance of a free government whereas the consolidation of the states into one vast republic, sure to be aggressive abroad and despotic at home, will be the certain precursor of that ruin which has overwhelmed all those that have preceded it. The appeal to states rights is of the most potent symbols of the american civil war, but confusion abounds as to the historical and present meaning of this federalist principle. List of books and articles about states rights online.
This page discusses the issue of states rights and its role in the coming of the civil war. Slavery, not states rights, caused civil war whose. Lincoln chose war to suppress what he deemed a rebellion in the southern states. Tate 2011 undertook a literary criticism of a major book by john taylor of. Confederates maintained that the principles of states rights and freedom from. Jun 02, 2017 but it also permeates mainstream discussions, from college essays to the huffington post. The civil war is believed by most to be caused because of the issue of slavery. It was incompatible with the inspiring words of our declaration of independence, we hold these. There can be no doubt that slavery was a blight upon the history of the united states. There is a mountain of evidence against that conclusion. The concept of states rights had been an old idea by 1860.
Theyre very interested, they buy our books, they know a lot of stuff about it, marten said. What is particularly glaring about president obama invoking states rights is that, as a constitutional attorney and the product of an interracial marriage, he certainly knows it is a flawed and offensive argument, particularly with regard to civil rights. States rights american battlefield trust civil war trust. States rights, yes that was his birth name, gist was an officer in the confederacy during the civil war he was a general in the south carolina militia and moved over to the regular confederate army during the civil war, he was one of the second or third echelon generals of the war, a group not that much is know about other then a pigion. Texas will finally teach that slavery was main cause of the civil war slavery has been upgraded to the primary cause in the curriculum, however states rights and sectionalism will still be. States rights and antislavery activism the journal of the. The american civil war bibliography comprises books that deal in large part with the american civil war. The civil war books that should have been assigned reading in. The myth of secession and states rights in the civil war. How the civil war and reconstruction remade the constitution. The american civil war is often viewed entirely as the north versus the south, but sandwiched in between these two battling areas were the border. Search the librarys online public access catalog to find holdings of general books on the civil war era, including military histories, bibliographies, and guides to other state and.
States rights gist september 3, 1831 november 30, 1864 was a lawyer, a militia general in south carolina, and a confederate army brigadier general who served during the american civil war. How did american southerners justify an institution that by the early nineteenth century had been abolished by nearly every state in the north. Regarding what caused the civil war also called civil war causes, the president of the united statesas commanderinchief and chief executivedeclared that the sole cause of the civil war was secession. Daniel webster he was a suporter of the union in the civil war and. The american civil war was a civil war in the united states from 1861 to 1865, fought between. What reconstructionera laws can teach our democracy the. For the last time, the american civil war was not about. This is a political cartoon that shows reasons for tension in the union. From james mcphersons definitive history to tony horwitzs adventures among obsessives, here are the 11 best books on the civil war in time. In american political discourse, states rights are political powers held for the state governments.
1613 1262 376 1378 969 459 1459 805 471 49 464 40 1098 792 757 496 659 752 999 991 100 1560 270 1427 848 779 156 603 65 1452 673 317 453 720 42 368 1113 1178 376 1100 944 288 1131 1368